Yes feel free to tag us if you’d like new results uploaded. If we anticipate more frequent uploads we will make the process more streamlined.
Hi @Gavin_Wang ,
could we get the following ILAMB results onto me.org please: /g/data/zv30/public/data/ILAMB_ESM16_Evaluation/ilamb_result/_build_07_07
These results are a replacement of the previous ones. We don’t need to keep the first results on me.org.
I’ll get those ILAMB results up on me.org
Just clarifying, we want to overwrite the existing run? If you’d like I can set up another analysis run if you want to keep the existing run for reference. It would take about the same time anyways.
I realise it’s the same time to do either, but we don’t want to keep the first set of results. These are probably not correct to compare to other results so removing them will avoid confusion.
The new results are now up at the same link: ModelEvaluation.org
Let us know if any additional analyses are required or any issues!
Thanks @Yuvraj_Singh
@alexnorton @RachelLaw @inh599 , there is something weird in the results. The comparison to Hoffman for the land source (under “GlobalNetEcosystemCarbonBalance”) shows the opposite compared to what we would expect: ESM1.6 is shown further away from Hoffman than ESM1.5.
Considering there are 2 identical ESM1.6 runs being used, I can’t quite see how it would be explained by a simple swap between the runs in the workflow. So not quite sure what is happening here.
@clairecarouge - my guess is that the plotted result for ESM1.6 does not include the land use change flux (but perhaps the ESM1.5 one does?). We’d need to check how this field has been created from the model output. It could mean that nbp from MOPPy isn’t correct since there are a couple of different ways to calculate it from the model output.
NEE against FLUXCOM also looks odd. ESM1.6 is closer to a mean of zero, as though it was from the preindustrial or start of the historical rather than from present-day.
Thanks both. These issues appear in the original ILAMB results too, so it’s an issue with the processing and not with how MEorg is handling it. I’ve passed on these notes to Rhaegar and Romain